In a mad world, all blogging is psychiatry blogging

My Thoughts On The First 40 Pages Of Alastair MacIntyre’s “After Virtue”, Expressed In The Form Of A Slightly Modified XKCD Comic

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to My Thoughts On The First 40 Pages Of Alastair MacIntyre’s “After Virtue”, Expressed In The Form Of A Slightly Modified XKCD Comic

  1. It seems like this result generalizes for philosophy as a whole. Especially amateur philosophers who’ve never had the exquisite experience of slogging through a discussion in a graduate-level seminar that’s not going anywhere. But as the example of MacIntyre shows, this can afflict famous professional philosophers too.

    Report comment

    • Oligopsony says:

      To some extent. But with MacIntyre in particular he’s not just saying he’s come up with this great new theory about x, it’s that he thinks that the existing pluralism about x is itself a shocking sign of cultural malaise.

      Report comment

  2. UA says:

    Hehe. I look forward to the full review.

    Report comment

  3. Oligopsony says:

    I also look forward to the full review. It looks like it might be a less mindkilly (but still fun) opportunity to discuss a lot of the ideas orbiting around Reaction.

    (Actually I suppose the other optimistic interpretation is that it serves as an excuse to discuss all the fun mindkilly stuff at once. Reaction! Marx! Aristotle-by-which-I-mean-Jesus!)

    Report comment

  4. Paul Torek says:

    Nice font choice for the XKCD edit. Chalk up another looking forward to the full review.

    Report comment